Original Anthony's NY Pizza

The Write-Up

The full story

The self declared original Anthony's of Orlando, slinging New York style pies since 1987 for Casselberry, Winter Park, and Maitland. The 18 inch Extravaganza loads up sausage, meatballs, and pepperoni, and the menu runs to wings, subs, and chicken parm.

District Stories

Orlando's long memory

The guide keeps the long memory of Orlando's districts in one place: the names, the plats and the stories behind the streets.

Browse the district stories →

Similar Feel

More places with this feel

Matched by vibe, not by neighborhood: the places across Greater Orlando closest in spirit to Original Anthony's NY Pizza.

Goodfella's Pizzeria

Pizza · Alafaya · $$

An old-school, no-frills slice shop on East Colonial Drive serving New York-style pies guests say taste like the kind they grew up eating.

11873 E Colonial Dr, Orlando, FL 32826

Lazy Moon Pizza

Pizza · University · $

UCF's divey, sticker-plastered college hangout, famous for slices bigger than your head and pies guests call ginormous.

11551 University Blvd, Orlando, FL 32817

Park Avenue Pizza

Pizza · Winter Park · $$

A no-frills, old-school counter on Lyman Avenue, where guests go for a quick slice done right.

119 E Lyman Ave, Winter Park, FL 32789

Victorio's II Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Italian · Winter Springs · $$

Serving Winter Springs since 1989, this spot is known for Detroit style deep dish baked in Detroit pans, sauce ladled on after.

Victorio's II Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria, 200 E State Rd 434, Winter Springs, FL 32708

Keep Going

More in Casselberry

Other places in Casselberry, closest to Original Anthony's NY Pizza first.

Bagel King Casselberry

Bakeries · Bagel Bakery · $

The Bagel King family's retail cafe, serving New York style kettle-baked bagels made fresh daily for breakfast and lunch.

Bagel King Casselberry, 1455 Semoran Blvd, Suite 113, Casselberry, FL 32707

Aji Ceviche Bar Casselberry

Latin & Caribbean · Peruvian · $$

Bright and unpretentious on State Road 436 in Casselberry, a Peruvian ceviche bar built on lime, heat, and fresh fish.

Aji Ceviche Bar Casselberry, 1436 State Road 436, Casselberry, FL 32707-6506, United States

Debbies Bar

Bars & lounges · Dive Bar · $

Debbies is a classic Casselberry dive on Semoran Boulevard, a small, old-school full liquor bar where the atmosphere stays fun and relaxing.

Debbies Bar, 1490 FL-436, Casselberry, FL 32707

Semoran Skateway

Attractions · Roller Skating Rink · $

Family owned since 1978, the roller rink generations of Casselberry kids grew up in, now with lessons and adult rhythm nights.

Semoran Skateway, 2670 Cassel Creek Blvd, Casselberry, FL 32707

An Vi Vietnamese Kitchen & Sandwich

Noodles & Southeast Asian · Vietnamese · $

House-made bone broth pho, fresh rolls, banh mi, vermicelli bowls, and Cajun fried rice with catfish at this bright Semoran Blvd kitchen.

An Vi Vietnamese Kitchen & Sandwich, 1052 FL-436, Casselberry, FL 32707

Aladdin Cafe

Mediterranean · Lebanese · $$

A family owned Lebanese kitchen on Semoran Blvd, 100 percent halal, dough hand-stretched daily and eggplants charred over flame.

Aladdin Cafe, 1015 FL-436, Casselberry, FL 32707