Black Magic Pizza

The Write-Up

The full story

Black Magic Pizza is the Milk District's punk rock pizza window on Bumby Avenue, playful in name and serious about dough, with basically no seating and parking that fills fast. The pies sit between Neapolitan and New Haven, slightly charred and hand tossed: the Dr. Pepperoni, the Hornets Nest with hot honey and soppressata, the Cheezus and the Tuscan Leather. Vegan pies get the same care as the classics, and regulars call the results some of the best pizza they have had anywhere.

District Story

The story of Milk District

One cow, twenty acres and a dairy on the edge of town: the neighborhood that grew up around the T.G. Lee plant and took its name from the milk.

Read the Milk District story →

Similar Feel

More places with this feel

Matched by vibe, not by neighborhood: the places across Greater Orlando closest in spirit to Black Magic Pizza.

Milk District Eats Food Tour

Attractions · Milk District · $$

A small-group walking food tour through the dairy-named district east of downtown, personal, easygoing and rich with local history.

201 N Bumby Ave, Orlando, FL 32803 (meets in front of the Milkhouse)

Sodough Square

Pizza · Milk District · $$

Detroit-style pizza from its original Michigan Street shop, all crispy, cheesy edges over pillowy soft dough.

Sodough Square, 419 E Michigan St, Orlando, FL 32806-4511

Park Avenue Pizza

Pizza · Winter Park · $$

A no-frills, old-school counter on Lyman Avenue, where guests go for a quick slice done right.

119 E Lyman Ave, Winter Park, FL 32789

Nuri's

Pizza · Orlando · $$

Downtown's tavern-style pizza joint on East Pine, all cracker-crisp, paper-thin crust party-cut into squares you keep grabbing.

Nuri's, 63 E Pine St, Orlando, FL 32801-2617, United States

Mario's Pizza

Pizza · Orlando · $$

Family-run on Curry Ford Road, where guests say the pies taste like real pizza from New York.

Mario's Pizza, 7213 Curry Ford Rd, Orlando, FL 32822-5805, United States

Goodfella's Pizzeria

Pizza · Alafaya · $$

An old-school, no-frills slice shop on East Colonial Drive serving New York-style pies guests say taste like the kind they grew up eating.

11873 E Colonial Dr, Orlando, FL 32826

Keep Going

More in Milk District

Other places in Milk District, Local Picks first, then the closest to Black Magic Pizza.

Iron Cow Local Pick

Japanese & sushi · Sushi · $$

Part hi-fi sushi lounge, part underground club, the Milk District's good contradiction.

2438 E Robinson St, Suite A, Orlando, FL 32803

Swine & Sons

Burgers & sandwiches · Sandwiches · $

Inside the Milkhouse on Bumby Avenue, Swine & Sons runs a casual sandwich counter with food hall energy and a pop punk playlist.

201 N Bumby Ave, Orlando, FL 32803

Beefy King

Burgers & sandwiches · Sandwiches · $

Orlando's old-school roast beef counter, steaming since 1968 and proudly no-frills about it.

Beefy King, 424 N Bumby Ave, Orlando, FL 32803-6028

Stasio's Italian Deli

Italian · $

An old-school Italian deli on Robinson Street where the warm bustle and market shelves make every visit feel like a small celebration.

2320 E Robinson St, Orlando, FL 32803

Tasty Takeover

Restaurants · Food Truck Event · $$

Every Tuesday night, food trucks take over the lots behind the Milk District bars for an easygoing block party.

2424 E Robinson St, Orlando, FL 32803

Sideward Brewing Co.

Breweries · Brewery · $$

A laid-back, unpretentious taproom on Bumby Avenue where beer is brewed clean and the kitchen is, in guests' words, severely underrated.

210 N Bumby Ave, Orlando, FL 32803